Baseball game for PS3

[Santo Del Negro]

What do you recommend? 2k game or The Show? TIA

[Absinthe]

The Show 

[eric in houston]

the show.

saw that 2k9 was voted worst video game of 2009 i cant see how 2k10 would be any good either.

[bman03]

2K10 is good enough to offer up a million bucks to the first person to pitch a perfect game.  2K might have sucked last year, but overall they make the best sports games period.

[Absinthe]

I would disagree about 2k sports. I have been disappointed with every game I've bought of theirs. they are the least realistic brand of sports games if you ask me. Go back and look at NCAA Basketball 2k3... you can score 80 pts with one player w/o even trying

[bman03]

College basketball games all suck.  NBA 2K has been the most consistent and best sports sim since Dreamcast.

[Santo Del Negro]

bman is a douche

therefore, i am going with The Show

[Turd Ferguson]

EA Sports MVP Baseball was by far the best baseball game until MLB didn't renew their contract.  The last one was 2006 I think.  I've tried most of the others since and I'd still rather play MVP 06

[Reed]

[Ralph In Orlando]

The MLB 2K10 Demo is out on the 360.... PS3 owners will have to wait until next week to play the demo...but by then, the game will already be out. The demo itself is great. Everything has improved from last year, and I didnt really hate last years all that much. Pitching is money. I cant hit worth a damn, but ill get the hang of it when I play with a real NY team. If you have trouble pitching, you need to complete your movement before the yellow circle gets too big.

[Ralph In Orlando]

MLB 2k10 is teh hit

[Saluki_Love]

I think I may trade in The Show 2009 for the new version. I heard you can call games as a catcher in the new Road To The Show. That sounds pretty sweet.